| Minute | Score | Indy Eleven | Cincinnati | |
| 7' | 0 - 1 |  Walker K. (Penalty) |
||
| 24' | 1 - 1 | McInerney J. |
||
| 30' | 2 - 1 | Ayoze (Penalty) |
||
| 41' | 2 - 2 | McLaughlin J. |
||
| 54' | 2 - 3 | Bone C. |
||
| 60' | 2 - 3 |  Lasso F. |
||
| 60' | 2 - 3 | Lewis N. (Steinberger Z.) |
||
| 60' | 2 - 3 | Watson M. (Speas B.) |
||
| 67' | 2 - 3 | Ledesma E. (Haber D.) |
||
| 72' | 2 - 3 | Welshman E. |
||
| 76' | 2 - 3 | Walker K. |
||
| 78' | 2 - 3 | Braun J. (Guerra J.) |
||
| 81' | 2 - 3 | Seymore W. (Bone C.) |
||
| 86' | 2 - 3 | Ameobi O. (Welshman E.) |
||
| 88' | 2 - 3 | Ayoze |
