| Minute | Score | Cincinnati | Columbus Crew | |
| 14' | 1 - 0 | Vazquez B. (Boupendza A.) |
||
| 65' | 1 - 0 |  Gressel J. (Farsi M.) |
||
| 65' | 1 - 0 | Gaddis R. (Arias S.) |
||
| 65' | 1 - 0 | Ramirez C. (Morris A.) |
||
| 73' | 1 - 0 | Acosta L. |
||
| 73' | 1 - 0 | Badji D. (Boupendza A.) |
||
| 75' | 1 - 1 | Powell A. (Own goal) |
||
| 76' | 1 - 1 | Zawadzki S. (Yeboah Y.) |
||
| 82' | 1 - 1 | Badji D. |
||
| 85' | 1 - 1 | Nwobodo O. (Kubo Y.) |
||
| 86' | 1 - 2 | Rossi D. |
||
| 91' | 1 - 2 | Cheberko Y. (Gressel J.) |
