| Minute | Score | Cincinnati | Columbus Crew | |
| 1' | 1 - 0 | Castillo E. (Acosta L.) |
||
| 17' | 1 - 0 |  Afful H. |
||
| 24' | 2 - 0 | Acosta L. (Atanga I.) |
||
| 28' | 2 - 0 | Castillo E. |
||
| 32' | 2 - 0 | Kubo Y. |
||
| 39' | 2 - 0 | Mensah J. |
||
| 42' | 2 - 0 |  Afful H. |
||
| 46' | 2 - 0 |  Abdul-Salaam S. (Kitchen P.) |
||
| 57' | 2 - 0 | Berry M. (Francis W.) |
||
| 57' | 2 - 0 | Keita A. (Wormgoor V.) |
||
| 61' | 2 - 0 | Vallecilla G. |
||
| 64' | 2 - 0 | Stanko C. (Medunjanin H.) |
||
| 72' | 2 - 0 | Barreal A. |
||
| 73' | 2 - 0 | Kovacevic F. (Barreal A.) |
||
| 73' | 2 - 0 | Vazquez B. (Atanga I.) |
||
| 75' | 2 - 0 | Parente I. (Hairston M.) |
||
| 75' | 2 - 0 | Hurtado E. (Matan A.) |
||
| 77' | 2 - 1 | Berry M. (Zelarayan L.) |
||
| 88' | 2 - 1 | Stanko C. |
