| 31 Luis Robles 4 Jamison Olave 5 Markus Holgersson 3 Heath Pearce 27 Kosuke Kimura 11 Dax McCarty 17 Tim Cahill 22 Jonny Steele 12 Eric Alexander 9 Fabian Espindola 14 Thierry Henry |
| Substitution |
| 8 Juninho Pernambucano 10 Lloyd Sam 7 Roy Miller 25 Brandon Barklage 16 Connor Lade 24 Santiago Castano 13 Marius Obekop |
| 30 Andy Gruenebaum 23 Kevan George 16 Eric Gehrig 2 Tyson Wahl 3 Joshua Williams 33 Federico Higuaín 8 Matías Sánchez 6 Tony Tchani 9 Justin Meram 12 Eddie Gaven 11 Dominic Oduro |
| Substitution |
| 5 Danny O´Rourke 19 Konrad Warzycha 13 Ethan Finlay 28 Matt Lampson 17 Ben Speas 18 Aaron Schoenfeld 21 Chad Barson |
